A Kingdom that has no End - A Second Crusade TL

Introduction
A Kingdom that has no End - A Second Crusade TL
1280px-Saint-Bernard_prêchant_la_2e_croisade,_à_Vézelay,_en_1146.jpg

Saint Bernard preaching the second crusade in Vézelay in 1146, Emile Signol

“Christian warriors, He who gave His life for you, today demands yours in return. These are combats worthy of you, combats in which it is glorious to conquer and advantageous to die. Illustrious knights, generous defenders of the Cross, remember the example of your fathers, who conquered Jerusalem, and whose names are inscribed in Heaven. Abandon then the things that perish, to gather unfading palms and conquer a Kingdom that has no end."
Bernard of Clairvaux at the Council of Vezelay, Easter Sunday of 1146.

December of 1144, the city of Edessa, capital of the Crusader County of Edessa, fell to Imad ad-Din Zengi and its Frankish population was massacred. This event would spark what we know as the Second Crusade, though Zengi would not live to see what he had provoked, as he died in the year 1146 and was succeeded by his sons, Nur ad-Din, Emir of Aleppo; and Sayf ad-Din, Emir of Mosul.

News of Edessa's fate trickled into Rome in the summer of 1145. Pope Eugenius III had just been elected when he was brought word of the disaster by Bishop Hugh of Jabala. Though it was not until late fall, that Eugenius finally issued a crusading bull: Quantum praedecessores, addressed to Louis VII and the Gauls, on 1 December 1145.
images - 2024-03-01T134426.143.jpeg

Louis VII kneeling before St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Gustave Dore

In the spring of 1146, the king of France held a council at Vezelay in Burgundy, where St. Bernard was to preach. Bernard, now an old man, had enormous prestige by this time, at his age, he was frail, and yet there he was, called by God, giving a rousing sermon. Louis knelt before the holy abbot and received his benediction. Hundreds of knights followed his example. Old enemies reconciled on the spot and joined the sacred endeavor. Bernard tore up his own cloak for cloth for crosses.
IMG_20240311_121741.jpg

Conrad III King of Germany

Bernard, was rallying Europe, searching for advocates for the Crusade. A brilliant speaker, Bernard was entering upon his last great work. Conrad III, king of the Romans, was deep in conflict with the pope, and his barons were unruly, thus he was unenthusiastic and prevaricated. He temporized, delayed, made excuses. Not until Christmas 1146, at Speyer, did Conrad finally agree to take the cross. There, Bernard preached a powerful sermon in which he spoke directly to Conrad. He portrayed the king as standing before Christ. "O man, what is there that I should have done for you and did not do?" The king yielded at last, and, as at Vezelay, a Christian king was joined by many of his nobles in an outburst of religious and martial enthusiasm.

For two years now reports and letters had come from Outremer stressing the wider danger. The whole movement was emotionally charged, because for this time the crusaders knew what they were doing. They had the precedent of the First Crusade, with all its heroes and legends, before them. They knew, too, that the risks were real, as the crusades of 1101 had taught. These crusaders were fully conscious of their charge, or so they thought.
________________
Author's notes:
This is my first TL, so there might be some errors in writing, I'm not really much experienced in writing. The idea of making a TL about the crusades, came to my mind after reading "And All Nations Shall Gather To It" of Ricard (i.e. Rdffigueira). I started to write this about a week ago, though I had been thinking about writing a TL about this for a while, choosing the Second Crusade over other crusades was because I didn't want to start to early, nor too late. So, I hope you have like this introduction so far.
 
Last edited:
The Emperor and the Road to Antioch
King Conrad departed in May 1147, with an army that was considered huge for this period, estimated around 20,000. Accompanied by his half brother, Bishop Otto of Freising; and his nephew, the future emperor, Frederick I, at this time only a teenager; they followed the route of the First Crusade up the Rhine River to Regensburg and down the Danube River. They had passed peaceably through Hungary, but in Byzantine territory there were quarrels over supplies and a few incidents of fighting. Like in the First Crusade, the Latins had created an unfavorable impression of themselves.

To prevent an escalation of the conflict between the Greeks and the Germans, Conrad accepted to cross the Hellespont to Asia Minor, instead of marching to the Bosporus [1]. Once in Lampsakos, negotiations between Conrad and Manuel reopened. It was stated that the Imperial Lands that the Crusaders might conquer, would be restored to the Empire. Conrad accepted to sign an alliance with Manuel against their mutual enemies, the Normans of Sicily, in exchange Manuel would sent a contingent of 3,000 men along with the Crusader army, under the leadership of Michael Palaiologos.[2]

In June 11, king Louis VII departs Metz with his wife, Queen Eleanor of Aquitaine, his forces are estimated to be around 7,000 men. Soon they arrived in the Kingdom of Hungary, where they were welcomed by king Géza II of Hungary. Due to his good relationships with Louis VII, Géza II asked the French king to be his son Stephen's godfather. Once they arrived in Byzantine lands they were met with silent treatment by locals, suspicious because of the German behaviour. They met with the German army in the eastern side of the Bosphorus by middle October.

As a way to gain the two kings in his side against the Normans, the Emperor invited them and the high ranking nobles to Constantinople, where he personally accompanied them in a tour of its churches and holy sites. Celebrating a banquet on their honour and wishing them luck on their journey. After returning, they would finally set out for Antioch in November 1.

The army totaled 30,000 men. Conrad sent his half-brother, Otto of Freising, with the camp followers, other non-combatants and 5,000 men to march down the coast; while he would delve into Central Anatolia.

In November 12, part of the army, including Conrad and the Roman Contingent (the geography of the region forced them to divide the army in various columns) were watering their horses in a small river, near Dorylaeum, when the Turks attacked. These men have grown hearing about the First Crusade, but they seem to have forgotten or ignored how the Turks operated, and how the First Battle of Dorylaeum was won; the Crusader army would have certainly lost, if it wasn't for the Byzantine contingent under Michael Palaiologos, that had experience in Anatolian warfare; it was ordered to build a camp, while the heavy cavalry tried to resist the Turkish attack. Once the camp was done, the cavalry retreated and dismounted, the heavily armored knights were ordered to hold the vanguard until reinforces arrived. King Louis, after hearing the news of the Turkish ambush, would quickly march to the site of the battle. Three hundred French knights charged against the Seljuks, who were forced to halt their attack on the camp, turning on the reinforcements. Conrad and Michael turned into an offensive position, along the line of Louis, Frankish reinforcements kept coming, making the Turkish line unable to hold. Fifty years after the Battle of Dorylaeum, the Crusader forces were once again victorious, the Second Battle of Dorylaeum was a Crusader victory. Losses are estimated to be twelve hundred men for the Crusaders and three thousand for the Seljuks.
Combat_deuxième_croisade.jpg

The Second Battle of Dorylaeum, 1147

The Crusaders continued their march in partial peace until they were near the town of Philomelion, Turkish raids were ever increasing. The Turks used the fact, that columns constantly separated from the vanguard to sack nearby villages to their advantage. The vanguard under Frederick of Hohenstaufen and Michael Palaiologos was ambushed by a major Turkish force, the Crusaders formed a circle and held their line until reinforcements arrived, the battle is mostly known for being the first victory of Frederick I, whose bravery and resilience in the moment gave the victory to his side.

The crusaders wanted a good place to celebrate Christmas, they knew Iconium was ideal, the capital of the Seljuk sultanate of Rum was the first major target of this crusade, though it would not fall without a fight. Outside the city they found plenty of water, a camp was built, waiting for what was about to come. The next day the Battle of Iconium would start, the Turkmen fought bravely, but their army wasn't made for pitched battle. A cavalry charge under Conrad managed to break the Turkish center. The battle was a decisive crusader victory, with Sultan Mesud being captured, along with prince Kilij Arslan in the aftermath of the victory.

images - 2024-03-10T153514.669.jpeg

The Battle of Iconium, Hermann Wislicenus

The city of Iconium wouldn't put much resistance, to prevent a worse fate, they knew hope was lost once the Sultan was captured. There the Crusaders camped in the sultan's park. Christmas was celebrated, the Christmas of 1097 had an air of consternation and fear, waiting for the outcome of the Siege of Antioch, fifty years later, Christmas was celebrated with great joy, many riches and food, that they deserved after weeks of shortages; the Emperor of the Romans would later get his own gift, in the form of Sultan Mesud, who was indirectly responsible of the death of his father and his brothers. After negotiations, the Crusaders had managed to guarantee safe passage in the rest of their way to Antioch, though they would take many noble Turkishmen, including prince Kilij Arslan, prisoner in order to ensure a safe voyage. Manuel used the situation to capture Ancyra, to then force the Sultan to sign a treaty that officially restored Iconium and Ancyra to imperial suzerainty, restricting the Seljuks to Koloneya and Caesarea.

The fall of Iconium sent shivers across the muslim world. Nur ad-Din would start preparing the defences of Aleppo, for he was conscious of what was about to come. Mu'in ad-Din Unur tried once again to restore his alliance with the Kingdom of Jerusalem, failing once again. Sayf ad-Din used the news of the threat the Crusaders now clearly pose to start uniting a coalition across the Muslim world.

Michael Palaiologos convinced the Crusaders to divide forces in the Cilician Mountains, in order to find Thoros II, who was hidden there after his escape from Constantinople, he was finally found with his brothers in the town of Vahka, an important stronghold in the region, and an old possession of the Rubenid family. The sight of the massive crusader army made Thoros realise that he had no option but to back down or he and his brothers would be killed and the town would be razed to the ground. He tried to negotiate better terms, but he was in no position to, he and his brothers were taken prisoner and later sent in a shipment to Constantinople.

King Conrad finally reunited with his half-brother, Bishop Otto, in the city of Tarsus. Luckily, the threat that the kings presented, prevented a major Turkish offensive against Otto's army and the pilgrims. They would finally arrive at Antioch in late February.
_________________
[1] In real life King Conrad refused to cross the Hellespont and instead marched to Constantinople.
[2] OTL, Manuel refused to send any Byzantine troops with the Crusaders due to their behaviour.
---
Author's notes:
Before writing this, I didn't acknowledge how much of a threat, the Seljuks of Rum actually were, they were pretty impressive during this period. If you wonder, what the POD is, it's basically Conrad being more conscious about the situation he's in and how important the Byzantine Empire is for the survival of the Crusader States; basically him being less of an idiot when dealing with Manuel, who would have been disposed to collaborate if it wasn't for Conrad's behaviour.
 
Last edited:
King Conrad departed in May 1147, with an army that was considered huge for this period, estimated around 20,000. Accompanied by his half brother, Bishop Otto of Freising; and his nephew, the future emperor, Frederick I, at this time only a teenager; they followed the route of the First Crusade up the Rhine River to Regensburg and down the Danube River. They had passed peaceably through Hungary, but in Byzantine territory there were quarrels over supplies and a few incidents of fighting. Like in the First Crusade, the Latins had created an unfavorable impression of themselves.

To prevent an escalation of the conflict between the Greeks and the Germans, Conrad accepted to cross the Hellespont to Asia Minor, instead of marching to the Bosporus [1]. Once in Lampsakos, negotiations between Conrad and Manuel reopened. It was stated that the Imperial Lands that the Crusaders might conquer, would be restored to the Empire. Conrad accepted to sign an alliance with Manuel against their mutual enemies, the Normans of Sicily, in exchange Manuel would sent a contingent of 3,000 men along with the Crusader army, under the leadership of Michael Palaiologos.[2]

In June 11, king Louis VII departs Metz with his wife, Queen Eleanor of Aquitaine, his forces are estimated to be around 7,000 men. Soon they arrived in the Kingdom of Hungary, where they were welcomed by king Géza II of Hungary. Due to his good relationships with Louis VII, Géza II asked the French king to be his son Stephen's godfather. Once they arrived in Byzantine lands they were met with silent treatment by locals, suspicious because of the German behaviour. They met with the German army in the eastern side of the Bosphorus by middle October.

As a way to gain the two kings in his side against the Normans, the Emperor invited them and the high ranking nobles to Constantinople, where he personally accompanied them in a tour of its churches and holy sites. Celebrating a banquet on their honour and wishing them luck on their journey. After returning, they would finally set out for Antioch in November 1.

The army totaled 30,000 men. Conrad sent his half-brother, Otto of Freising, with the camp followers, other non-combatants and 5,000 men to march down the coast; while he would delve into Central Anatolia.

In November 12, part of the army, including Conrad and the Roman Contingent (the geography of the region forced them to divide the army in various columns) were watering their horses in a small river, near Dorylaeum, when the Turks attacked. These men have grow hearing about the First Crusade, but they seem to have forgotten or ignored how the Turks operated, and how the First Battle of Dorylaeum was won; the Crusader army would have certainly lost, if it wasn't for the Byzantine contingent under Michael Palaiologos; it was ordered to build a camp, while the heavy cavalry tried to resist the Turkish attack. Once the camp was done, the cavalry retreated and dismounted, the heavily armored knights were ordered to hold the vanguard until reinforces arrived. King Louis, after hearing the news of the Turkish ambush, would quickly march to the site of the battle, this battle would see the first of the many famous cavalry charges of king Louis during this crusade. Three hundred French knights charged against the Seljuks, who were forced to halt their attack on the camp, turning on the reinforcements. Conrad and Michael turned into an offensive position, along the line of Louis, Frankish reinforcements kept coming, making the Turkish line unable to hold. Fifty years after the Battle of Dorylaeum, the Crusader forces were once again victorious, the Second Battle of Dorylaeum was a Crusader victory. Losses are estimated to be twelve hundred men for the Crusaders and three thousand for the Seljuks.
View attachment 893755
The Second Battle of Dorylaeum, 1147
The Crusaders continued their march in partial peace until they were near the town of Philomelion, Turkish raids were ever increasing. The Turks used the fact, that columns constantly separated from the vanguard to sack nearby villages to their advantage. The vanguard under Frederick of Hohenstaufen and Michael Palaiologos was ambushed by a major Turkish force, the Crusaders formed a circle and held their line until reinforcements arrived, the battle is mostly known for being the first victory of Frederick I, whose bravery and resilience in the moment gave the victory to his side.

The crusaders wanted a good place to celebrate Christmas, they knew Iconium was ideal, the capital of the Seljuk sultanate of Rum was the first major target of this crusade, though it would not fall without a fight. Outside the city they found plenty of water, a camp was built, waiting for what was about to come. The next day the Battle of Iconium would start, the Turkmen fought bravely, but their army wasn't made for pitched battle. A cavalry charge under Conrad III and Louis VII managed to break the Turkish center, the Charge of the Crusader Kings it was called, one of the most depicted moments in history. The battle was a decisive crusader victory, with Sultan Mesud and prince Kilij Arslan being captured.
View attachment 893756
The Battle of Iconium, Hermann Wislicenus
The city of Iconium wouldn't put much resistance, to prevent a worse fate, they knew hope was lost once the Sultan was captured. There the Crusaders camped in the sultan's park. Christmas was celebrated, the Christmas of 1097 had an air of consternation and fear, waiting for the outcome of the Siege of Antioch, fifty years later, Christmas was celebrated with great joy, many riches and food, that they deserved after weeks of shortages; the Emperor of the Romans would later get his own gift, in the form of Sultan Mesud, who was indirectly responsible of the death of his father and his brothers. The crusaders had managed to guarantee safe passage in the rest of their way to Antioch, though they would take many noble Turkishmen, including prince Kilij Arslan, prisoner in order to ensure a safe voyage. Manuel used the situation to capture Ancyra, forcing the Sultan to sign a treaty that officially restored Iconium and Ancyra to imperial suzerainty, restricting the Seljuks to Koloneya and Caesarea.

The fall of Iconium sent shivers across the muslim world. Nur ad-Din would start preparing the defences of Aleppo, for he was conscious of what was about to come. Mu'in ad-Din Unur tried once again to restore his alliance with the Kingdom of Jerusalem, failing once again. Sayf ad-Din used this news to unite a coalition against the Crusaders.

King Conrad finally reunited with his half-brother, Bishop Otto, in the city of Tarsus. Tensions arise due to the presence of the Byzantine contingent, whose leader claimed Cilicia as a part of the Empire; Lord Thoros of Cilicia preferred to back down, and recognised the authority of the Emperor of the Romans, in fear of the Crusader army. They would finally arrive at Antioch in late February.
_________________
[1] In real life King Conrad refused to cross the Hellespont and instead marched to Constantinople.
[2] OTL, Manuel refused to send any Byzantine troops with the Crusaders due to their behaviour.
---
Author's notes:
Before writing this, I didn't acknowledge how much of a threat, the Seljuks of Rum actually were, they were pretty impressive during this period. If you wonder, what the POD is, it's basically Conrad being more conscious about the situation he's in and how important the Byzantine Empire is for the survival of the Crusader States; basically him being less of an idiot when dealing with Manuel, who would have been disposed to collaborate if it wasn't for Conrad's behaviour.

these first two chapters are really very interesting, excellent that Conrad together with Louis caused less animosity with the Byzantine establishment compared to Otl, allowing Manuel to send auxiliary troops with them ( really important detail considering that the Normans at this moment were taking advantage of the crusade and Manuel's focus on it, to attack the empire again in Otl ) also a better starting relationship between Conrad and Manuel is really great ( the two eventually became close friends in Otl and there was discussion of a possible marriage between Henry Berengar or possibly Frederick I and a niece of Manuel ) the description of the central Anatolian campaign is very beautiful, with the victories at Iconium and Freddie's first successful battle in his career ( or the impression that Manuel Paleologos will be able to become occurrence an important character in Outremer, or quite famous in Europe for his exploits on the crusade ) so we have the kingdom of Cilicia returning under Byzantine rule ( control directly or as vassalage ? ) well remembering that John II originally wanted to put Manuel in charge of a kingdom in this area, including Armenian Cilicia and Antioch, given his Latinophilia and key role as a link between Byzantium and Outremer, I can see that the Emperor will know how to manage the government of this territory at its best ( i.e. respecting local traditions, now with an important Frankish component in them ) I am very curious to see how it will continue, especially because the second Crusade is so little used compared to the first or third Crusades, much more common in TL, Consider me on board for this adventure which promises to be interesting ( I also have a weakness for the Staufer, Corrado is so little used compared to the two Freddie and Henrich VI )
 
Nice new series, I've always wanted to read a Crusader TL that isn't knee-deep with hundreds of chapters. Great that the Second Crusade is a success instead of being the failure of OTL. I wonder how things will go with better relations between the HRE and ERE? Hopefully we can get a lot of maps/portraits/battle paintings/etc. Keep up the good work, liked and subbed 👍👍👍👍.
 
Real great stuff! The Turks of rum seem to have been dealt a fatal blow, that’ll definitely have some huge implications for the ERE. Now that they’ve broken into central Anatolia, Manuel will no doubt be able to retake most of its Anatolian territory back very soon if he keeps the pressure up.

Definitely gonna be a very different crusade, I wonder if the county of Edessa will be restored?
 
Cool timeline? Here are a few questions: with the Muslim world focused on the loss of the Levant, could the Norman Kingdom of Sicily have greater success in holding onto Tunisia and expanding into North Africa? Also, could trade ensure that Ethiopia is far more developed?
 
Cool timeline? Here are a few questions: with the Muslim world focused on the loss of the Levant, could the Norman Kingdom of Sicily have greater success in holding onto Tunisia and expanding into North Africa? Also, could trade ensure that Ethiopia is far more developed?


technically the Altavillas already had a fair amount of dominion in the current region of Tunisia and Tripolitania, starting from the campaigns of Roger II in 1135, but only after 1148, when Sicilian control in the area was consolidated, this kingdom based its backbone, on Muslims loyal to the Norman rule and above all on the Christian minority still present in North Africa ( these populations were mainly located in southern Tunisia, and speaking the African Romance dialect, as testified by the North African geographer Idrisi, we know that Roger II to fortify his hold on the territory , had in mind to create new settlements with a Christian majority, coming from his peninsular possessions or friendly territories ) but his sudden death in 1154 ( and the contemporary war against Byzantium ) created the conditions for which the Norman power began to weaken, something which the Almohads immediately took advantage of, and began a series of clashes which then led to this seizure of power by the Almohads in 1160, at the end of the kingdom ( the last Norman stronghold in the region to fall was Mahdia ), causing the acceleration of the end of the local Christian community, considered by the new government as a dangerous fifth column, I now believe that rather than trying to expand further into the region, the Hauteville rulers who followed Roger should focus on expanding their local support base and fortifying the border regions with Tripolitania and modern-day Algeria, in order to force the enemy to a series of tiring sieges that allow the defenders to have plenty of time to reorganize and attack, but it would be necessary for the Almohads to also have problems elsewhere ( such as in Morocco or Andalusia ) so as to have to divide their attention and resources on multiple fronts
 
The Zengid Brothers, Antioch and the Siege of Aleppo
"Whoever wants to conquer the Levant should first seize Aleppo. Whoever seizes Aleppo will seize the whole East."
Asad ad-Din Shirkuh to Nur ad-Din

IMG_20240316_120451.jpg

Imam ad-Din Zengi

"Alas! This great star of Islam eclipsed! This great supporter of the faith died". The death of Atabeg Zengi in the hands of a Frankish slave was an stroke of luck for the Crusader cause, he's often considered one of the most successful Muslim rulers at dealing with the Franks. He was succeeded by his sons, Sayf ad-Din, as Emir of Mosul; and Nur ad-Din, as Emir of Aleppo; the Khabur river was set as the frontier between the two kingdoms.

After securing Aleppo, Nur ad-Din attacked the Principality of Antioch and took Edessa from Count Joscelin, who had used the death of Zengi to recapture the city, Joscelin barely managed to escape with 20 knights. After the incident the male population of Edessa was massacred, and the women and children enslaved. The city was razed to the ground, so it wouldn't be a reliable base for count Joscelin. Michael the Syrian estimates, from both sieges of Edessa, 30,000 deaths, with 16,000 people enslaved.

He then, formed an alliance with Mu'in al-Din, governor of Damascus, by marrying his daughter, in exchange Nur ad-Din received Homs. After that, helped Mu'in ad-Din in pacifying Bosra, defeating king Baldwin, who was helping the rebels, in battle.

Little is known about the activities of Sayf ad-Din during the first years of his reign, he imprisoned Alp Arslan, claimant to the city of Mosul. An important episode was a meet with his brother, in which both agreed to meet away from the armed forces, and both would have five hundred horsemen with them, but Sayf ad-Din only brought five, the story narrates:

Sayf ad-Din addressed Nur ad-Din, "Why did you not come to me? Did you fear that I might kill you? By Allah, I have never thought of such a thing. What do possessions avail? With whom will I live and from whom should I seek support, if I behave so dishonestly with my brother and the most beloved person to me?"

Nur ad-Din felt relaxed and safe. Hence, he returned to Aleppo. He equipped his army and came back with his soldiers but this time in the service of his brother Sayf ad-Din, who said to him, "I have no interest in your staying here. My purpose was that I wanted the Frankish kings to know that we are on good terms with each other so that they might stay away from us."


---

RaymondOfPoitiersWelcomingLouisVIIinAntioch.JPG

Raymond of Poitiers welcoming Louis VII in Antioch

The arrival of the Crusaders at Antioch was met with great bliss. Prince Raymond of Poitiers welcomed the kings and showed them every hospitality, queen Eleanor (Raymond's niece) was especially captivated by the life at Antioch, that reminded her of her native Aquitaine. This hospitality was clearly a method of preventing the kings from going south, and instead helping him to expand eastwards. Raymond had long ambitioned the cities of Aleppo and Caesarea Germanica, he had previously try to capture Aleppo with the help of Emperor John, but failed, now with the kings here he thought his ambitions could finally be accomplished.

Though Prince Raymond was glad about the arrival of the Crusader force, it had brought an unpleasant consequence with it; the extension of imperial power in Central Anatolia, and the consolidation of their hold over Cilicia gave Manuel an easier way to exert influence over Antioch; a few years prior Manuel had already force him to visit Constantinople and pay homage to him; given this new conditions his situation had significantly worsen. Thus, he delayed to directly speak to Michael Palaiologos the longer he could, he searched for German support, but it was clear that their king supported Manuel over him; he tried to convince king Louis to support his cause, but he would refuse, even with queen Eleanor trying to convince him that he shouldn't, this would further worsen their relation. The lack of French support convinced Prince Raymond that he had no option, but to present himself to general Palaiologos as loyal to the empire. Surprisingly, general Michael had not bring the issue of the patriarchate of Antioch, probably to prevent the alienation of his allies. After this events Michael and his army marched south with the pilgrims.

A council was called, in order to discuss how they would proceed, almost everyone agreed that it was necessary to rid with Nur ad-Din and avenge what was done to Edessa, the real discussion was how. In the previous days Raymond had been discussing the idea of aiming for Aleppo with king Louis, as always queen Eleanor agreed with his uncle; who argued that the only way of neutralizing the Zengid threat was capturing his power base; at the end he would convince king Louis of supporting him in the council. Bishop Otto and King Conrad argued that their goal should be uniting forces with Count Joscelin in Turbessel, in order to restore the County of Edessa. The discussion didn't go for long, marching to Edessa would never be safe without getting rid of Nur ad-Din and Nur ad-Din would forever be a threat with Aleppo in his hands. Though, Conrad convinced them to send a separate army to unite with the forces of Joscelin, which number they overestimated.

By the time of their arrival in Antioch the crusader numbers had diminished, of the 30,000 strong army 4,000 had perished in Anatolia, and the Byzantine contingent had left between, 23,000 was what remained, adding that to Prince Raymond army, disposing of 400 knights and a 1,000 footmen.

It was decided that 19,000 men under King Louis, King Conrad and Prince Raymond would march to lay siege to Aleppo; while 5,000 under Frederick of Hohenstaufen, Ottakar of Styria and Alfonso Jordan would march to Cyrrhus, and then to Aintab in order to unite with the forces of Count Joscelin in Turbessel, with the purpose of preventing reinforcements from the Emir of Mosul of relieving the siege. The papal legate, Cardinal Theodwin, was sent to arrange a coordinated offensive against the ruler of Damascus with King Baldwin III, in order to prevent him from relieving Aleppo; he was also sent to deal with Count Raymond II of Tripoli, with the purpose of forcing him to join the crusade, which he was evading due to the presence of Alfonso Jordan, who claimed the County of Tripoli as his rightful possession.

The road to Aleppo was very peaceful when compared to the Anatolian roads, the crusaders naturally expected a battle they didn't found, small contingents that were supposed to halt their advance couldn't do much as the crusaders had the support from the local population, as the area had only been recently conquered by Zengi; quickly they had reached Zardana and retake it. After that, it didn't take long for them to heard what was happening, Nur ad-Din had anticipated the siege and left the city in order to unite forces with his brother. Some argue that they should retreat and march to Turbessel in order to prevent its fall and the destruction of the second Crusader army, but the kings refused; even Conrad, whose nephew was in command of that army argued that Nur ad-Din was expecting that. They would decide to only send messengers to tell the second army to retreat to Antioch, they didn't arrive in time. The towns taken by Zengi were quickly retook and the siege of Aleppo started in the 10th of May.

Nur ad-Din quickly captured many towns around Turbessel, including Aintab, near that town he found the second Crusader army. The battle of Aintab was the first defeat of the crusade, they had heard news of the Zengid army, but didn't expect to encounter it before reaching Turbessel, nor their numbers. The ambush was effective, but Nur ad-Din wouldn't be able to destroy the whole Crusader army, that thanks the bravery of Alfonso Jordan, whose charge and ability to hold his position allowed some of his comrades to escape. Of the five thousand strong army, only fifteen hundred survived the battle, with Alfonso Jordan dying in the field. The battle allowed Nur ad-Din to safely start the siege of Turbessel.

After the battle of Iconium Sayf ad-Din had been amassing a coalition against the crusaders, that numbered 20,000 men, under his command; an impressive number nonetheless, but he was expecting more tu unite to his cause, which couldn't happen, as the Caliph and the Seljuk Sultan were busy dealing with rebellions. By the middle of May he met the 8,000 strong army of his brother in the gates of Turbessel, who had been waiting for his arrival, as he needed siege weapons. The city of Turbessel resisted until June 1, when it was taken by assault. Well known, is the heroism of Count Joscelin, since he and his knights fought until the last men; so much was his excellence, that he would later be recognised as a martyr and a Saint of the Catholic church. The head of Count Joscelin was sent to the caliph of Baghdad in a silver chest. No man in Turbessel was spared, and the women and children were enslaved; this was how the Zengid brothers tried to show the Crusaders what happens to the infidels. After the fall of Turbessel most of the County of Edessa submitted to the Zengid brothers in fear of a similar fate, this allowed them to quickly get to Hazart, in the frontiers of the Principality of Antioch by June 30.

images - 2024-03-16T161042.886.jpeg

The city of Aleppo

Aleppo was one of the greatest and oldest cities of the Levant, it was considered as the gate of the Levant, and its garrison consisted of 5,000 men. The Crusaders were well prepared for the siege, they camped in the Eastern bank of the Queiq river, some weapons and materials were prepared beforehand, the supply lines were seemingly safe, the surrounding towns were easily taken and it was expected to get more weapons from the Italian republics soon. The arrival of Frederick sent shivers across the camp, the news of the major losses certainly flustered many, though it was later considered that Nur ad-Din wasn't an immediate threat given this prospect, as he would be occupied with Turbessel for long, at the end, they silently accepted the idea of giving up on Turbessel. Things calmed down, until an Armenian merchant arrived, he informed the Crusaders of the reunion of the Zengid brothers' forces, with the greatest army seen since the First Crusade; and perhaps most devastatingly, they heard about the fall of Turbessel and the death of Count Joscelin, they had been expecting Turbessel to resist for months, so this news felt like cold water; it spread a feeling of fear and uncertainty across the camp and the Latin states in the Levant.

After hearing about the start of the siege of Hazart, the operation was now under a clear threat, the possibility of the Zengids advancing all the way Zardana or even further was untenable, supply lines would be cut and they would be forced to retire; but they knew that if they all abandoned their camp what they had achieved would be undone. Preparations were made for king Louis to fight the Zengids, the minor towns were abandoned, most of the available horses were spent on this mission; 3,000 knights marched with him to battle

King Louis was never expected to inherit the throne as a second son, he was raised to be a priest, something that his personality made clear, he might not have been the ideal of a king, but he represented well the spirit of the crusades. Hazart fell, but that was expected. In the 15th of July, the Zengid army was marching south after departing Hazart, with Nur ad-Din leading the vanguard. Near the town of Afrin, king Louis had hidden behind a hill waiting for the Turkish force, dividing his force in fifteen squadrons. He then sprung his ambush, first 10 squadrons, while he held back waiting for the right moment; when he saw it, he charged down the hill like a starving lion, in a moment that was seemingly divine guidance, as Nur ad-Din was surrounded and unhorsed, though it's not known who killed him king Louis and count Thierry are often depicted as the responsibles. Even though, the Emir was dead the fierce Turks didn't lose their discipline, thanks to the warrior Shirkuh, who managed to halt the Crusader charge and reorganize the remaining forces. Scouts informing about the proximity of the main Muslim army and general Shirkuh forced king Louis to retreat, he ordered to take the body of Nur ad-Din and every prisoner possible. Twelve hundred knights were lost in the battle, but their prowess is legendary. The battle of Afrin immortalised king Louis, and after it he was the called, Louis the Lion. Sayf ad-Din swore to take revenge on the Franks, but he knew what the death of his brother would mean for Aleppo and there was no point on advancing further, so he retreated.

Bohemund_of_taranto_in_the_battle.jpg

The death of Nur ad-Din

The garrison of Aleppo tried to use the reduction of the Crusader forces to sortie them, but it was to no avail; king Conrad destroyed their forces and the prisoners were beheaded in front of the walls, the garrison lost fifteen thousand men. The return of king Louis to the camp brought another body with him, Nur ad-Din, his body was shown along with the men taken prisoner from the battle of Afrin. The garrison accepted to surrender if given safe passage. Though the crusaders wanted to avenge what was made to Edessa, they accepted the proposal, as king Louis thought that Sayf ad-Din continued his advance and was already sieging Zardana; this confusion spared the city of what could have been a massacre. The Crusaders finally entered the city in July 22 and later they were informed about the retreat of Sayf ad-Din.

What they expected to be a massive exodus was rather disappointing, and what they expected to be one of the greatest cities in the world was in a period of reconstruction, as years prior the city had been destroyed by an earthquake, and even though most of their inhabitants fled before the event, thus surviving; many never returned, making it a great city with an small population. Only ten years later the siege was felt for the inhabitants as another earthquake, the Crusaders said that they would allow them to practice their religion, but they would not stay, as the ones who stayed the last time all died.

Some pillaged what the citizens had left, and some excavated ruins that the earthquake left to find riches, many were found and many poor men became rich. A victory that great had not been seen, since the capture of Jerusalem. King Conrad ordered a cross to be built, and once made it was put in the highest tower of the Great Mosque of Aleppo, once the garden of the Cathedral of Saint Helena; it was named a Cathedral, there king Conrad gave a rousing speech, saying that the crusade was not yet over, and that their duty wouldn't be finished till the enemies of God were neutralised.

Debate arise over who should rule the city, normally the first standard to fly over the walls of the city represented a strong claim, but this time the city was not taken by conquest. Raymond had long wanted the city for himself and expected that it would be given to him, count Thierry of Flanders and margrave Ottakar of Styria started to claim the city once the siege started, a minor faction advocated for giving it to the son of the deceased count Joscelin, also named Joscelin, but found little support. Both Raymond and Thierry approached king Louis in search of support, though king Louis really appreciated Raymond, Thierry had a better offer; would king Louis support his claim and in exchange Thierry accepted to support the king in any war within France; once Raymond realised that king Louis wouldn't support him he was furious, and decided to use queen Eleanor against her husband, further deteriorating their relation; king Louis wouldn't back down, but an agreement was reached; Thierry would get the city, but as a vassal of Raymond. Even though Conrad would have supported Ottakar in other situation, he recognised that the victory was a merit of the king of France, so he preferred to let the city to the will of Louis. Thierry was declared count of Aleppo.

A council was called in order to debate how to proceed, most, including king Conrad advocated that they should march to Edessa, as the Zengid power had diminished with the death of Nur ad-Din and the county was of young Joscelin by right. Even though prince Raymond was opposed to this idea, little he could do. They departed Aleppo in August 30.
 
Last edited:
these first two chapters are really very interesting, excellent that Conrad together with Louis caused less animosity with the Byzantine establishment compared to Otl, allowing Manuel to send auxiliary troops with them ( really important detail considering that the Normans at this moment were taking advantage of the crusade and Manuel's focus on it, to attack the empire again in Otl ) also a better starting relationship between Conrad and Manuel is really great ( the two eventually became close friends in Otl and there was discussion of a possible marriage between Henry Berengar or possibly Frederick I and a niece of Manuel ) the description of the central Anatolian campaign is very beautiful, with the victories at Iconium and Freddie's first successful battle in his career ( or the impression that Manuel Paleologos will be able to become occurrence an important character in Outremer, or quite famous in Europe for his exploits on the crusade ) so we have the kingdom of Cilicia returning under Byzantine rule ( control directly or as vassalage ? ) well remembering that John II originally wanted to put Manuel in charge of a kingdom in this area, including Armenian Cilicia and Antioch, given his Latinophilia and key role as a link between Byzantium and Outremer, I can see that the Emperor will know how to manage the government of this territory at its best ( i.e. respecting local traditions, now with an important Frankish component in them ) I am very curious to see how it will continue, especially because the second Crusade is so little used compared to the first or third Crusades, much more common in TL, Consider me on board for this adventure which promises to be interesting ( I also have a weakness for the Staufer, Corrado is so little used compared to the two Freddie and Henrich VI )
You're right, Michael will have quite an important role in the rest of the second crusade. For the time being Cilicia is part of the empire, though it's clear that for it's geography it's a pretty autonomous area, but with the advances in Central Anatolia this might change.
Cool timeline? Here are a few questions: with the Muslim world focused on the loss of the Levant, could the Norman Kingdom of Sicily have greater success in holding onto Tunisia and expanding into North Africa? Also, could trade ensure that Ethiopia is far more developed?
I have to admit that you've read my mind, one of the first things that I prepared about this scenario is about Norman Africa, I mean, one of the reasons I chose the second crusade and not the third is literally Norman Africa and the other are the Komnenoi.

About Ethiopia, relations with them will certainly change and may develop, but it will need more Christian presence in the Red Sea.
 
The End of the Second Crusade
The governor of Damascus
Previously an ally of Jerusalem, Mu'in ad-Din had allied with Nur ad-Din after giving him the hand of his daughter.

The responsibilities of Michael Palaiologos were extended, as Manuel had ordered him to march with Cardinal Theodwin and act on his interest to to get the favour of the pope and increase Roman influence over Jerusalem. As the papal legate, Cardinal Theodwin forced count Raymond II to join the crusade, by threatening him with excommunication.

The first move of king Baldwin was supporting a rebellion in Bosra, but it was quickly crushed. As the kings of the Franks and the Romans had decided to siege Aleppo, it was decided that a council would be held in Tripoli, in order to decide how to proceed against the ruler of Damascus, and prevent him from relieving Aleppo.

ConcilAkra2.jpg

The council of Tripoli
The council was held in the 1st of June. It was decided that the objectives would be Baalbek and Hama. There was discussion about if they should aim for Homs or for Hama, Hama was ultimately chosen because it was seen as more defensible than Homs due to its connection to the Orontes River that gave it an easy communication with Antioch, also because of Hama's presence in the Bible, where it is referred as the Northern Border of the kingdom promised to the Children of Israel.

By this time 3k men had arrived in the ports of Acre and Jaffa, and more were expected to arrive in the following months. Their army was conformed as follows. King Baldwin alone had 950 knights and 6k footmen, Michael Palaiologos commanded the Byzantine contingent of twenty-five hundred men (five hundred were lost in Anatolia) and Raymond II had 200 knights and 700 footmen. King Baldwin and Michael marched to Hama, while Raymond and the recently arrived men prepared to cross the Lebanon Mountains.

Before reaching Hama they had to take the castle of Mont Ferrand, a crusader castle that was took by the forces of Zengi years prior. For the task Michael demanded the aid of the emir of Shaizar, who had swore fealty to Emperor John and in the eyes of Manuel was still his vassal; the emir in fear of becoming the next target of the crusaders, accepted to help. The castle fell after fifteen days, it was given to the Knights Hospitaller, as Raymond II sold them the rights of the castle years prior.

images - 2024-04-21T161553.531.jpeg

The old city of Hama

The cooperation of Shaizar made the siege Hama much easier, as it gave them the control of the Orontes River. The siege went rather smoothly, because Mu'in ad-Din preferred to focus on the Beqaa, as he had little control over the North of his realm and losing it would create a real threat to Damascus. Hama fell in the 10th of September, Salamiyah followed, resistance would survive for months in the castle of Shmemis, but it would eventually be abandoned. King Baldwin preferred to wait to see the outcome of the war the Zengids to decide who he would grant the city to, as he thought of giving it to Joscelin in case Edessa could not be retaken.

The governor of Damascus had expected the crossing of the Lebanon, as the fertile land of the Beqaa had long been ambitioned by the Franks and specifically the count of Tripoli. In a narrow passage Raymond was ambushed, he barely survived and was captured along a handful knights, being sent to Damascus. Mu'in ad-Din proceeded to cross the Lebanon, plundering the land of the count, though he didn't really try a major siege he sacked the towns of Aqurah, Lifhid, Le Boutron and ravaged the land around Byblos.

After hearing about the fall of Aleppo the governor of Damascus was wise to start negotiations, knowing that Franks kept arriving in the shores of the Levant and the kings would soon be free to march south. He accepted to give up on Hama (where he didn't really have much control) and liberated Raymond, the captured Franks and the occupied land in exchange of 80k dinars, his sovereignty over Homs and Bosra was recognised along with his authority over the Burid emir of Damascus, Mujir ad-Din Abaq, whom he imprisoned after his return to Damascus.

440px-Baldwin_of_Boulogne_entering_Edessa_in_Feb_1098.jpeg

Baldwin of Boulogne, first king of Jerusalem and count of Edessa

The brief attempt for Edessa and the ambitions of the prince
Almost 7k men had perished in the actions that leaded to the capture of Aleppo, and 3k men had decided to stay to garrison the captured fortresses, towns and cities, many submitting to count Thierry, who stayed in Aleppo, to confirm his hold over it.

Cyrrhus quickly submitted to the crusaders, after the event a minor force of 3k men under Prince Raymond was sent to capture Germanicia, while the main 12k men force marched to Turbessel. The army of the prince was met with constant harassment by the Danishmend turks, who had united to the coalition of Sayf ad-Din to get Germanicia. The Danishmendids were force to give battle, as they didn't have the support of the locals, Zunnun, beylik of Malatya was in the battle of the Aksu river, south of Germanicia, after which prince Raymond captured the city thanks to the support of the local population.

Instead of fighting a battle Sayf ad-Din opted for a scorched earth policy in the road to Turbessel, with the land being denude of resources; while mounted archers and small armies constantly harassed the crusaders. Thus, he slowed the crusader advance and made them dependent of Antioch and Aleppo. To prevent them from having an important base from where to support a siege to Turbessel he dismantled the walls of Aintab. The usage of heavy cavalry made the crusaders able to consistently defeat the Muslims in pitched battles, but for this campaign it was detrimental. But not everything was in favour of the emir, as the Artuqids had left after the death of Nur ad-Din and the Danishmendids had abandoned their alliance after the battle of the Aksu River; they represented more than a third of his army, which put him in an uncomfortable position when dealing with the Franks.

The strategy of Sayf ad-Din was simple, harass the crusaders, refuse to give battle and force them to leave once winter is close. He did not have hopes of taking Aleppo soon, and didn't want a long term conflict with the Franks, as his base of power was far from the Levant and without Aleppo he couldn't exercise much influence there. He saw the Artuqids as the immediate threat to his power and resented them because they left after the death of his brother, he knew that their ruler had previously allied with the Franks against his brother, a possibility that could repeat and would end up with him being surrounded. So, once winter was close he sent envoys for peace.

The treaty went as follows. Sayf ad-Din renounced to his claims to Aleppo and the land around it, along with the cities of Cyrrhus and Germanicia (which passed to prince Raymond); Beatrice of Saone, acting in the name of young Joscelin, renounced to the claims of the county of Edessa. It was argued about the return of the body of Joscelin II, but the emir was firm that he wouldn't pay the Caliph for it, most likely because it would damage his credibility among other Muslims. The treaty has often been criticised by Christian chroniclers, but in the eyes of the kings it might have seem extremely favourable, given their situation. Sayf ad-Din has also been criticised for not giving the decisive blow, but it's unlikely that he would have been able to take Aleppo even if he got rid of the kings of the Franks and the Romans, as for the nature of the previous siege, its walls weren't importantly damaged and he would be forced to fight in unfavorable position.

The crusaders returned to Antioch. A mass was hold in honour of count Joscelin II and the dead on campaign. They lavishly celebrated Christmas and their victory over the Turks. Young Joscelin was proclaimed count of Hama.

Conrad departed Antioch with his army once winter was over, while Louis stayed, the prince convinced him to. Raymond had long ambitioned the city Shaizar he had failed to take it before, because of the Zengids, but now they were gone and he remained. He wasn't supposed to attack it, as the emir had remained loyal to the emperor, but this was a holy war. Louis, whose character was close to that of a zeal accepted to help him. Manuel protested at the news, but he was busy with the king of Sicily and Michael didn't have the numbers to withstand the king of the Franks, while Conrad couldn't care less. Shaizar fell in May, the emir was executed along with sons, only one escaped, he was never found, but the prince had heard from a rumour, that was most likely false, that he was hiding in the Assassin fortress of Masyaf.

Masyaf_TheCastle.jpg

Castle of Masyaf

The Assassin had captured and bought many castles between the lands of the count of Tripoli and the prince of Antioch in the years prior, the reason why the Franks didn't outright condemn the order was because they feared the possibility of the Assassins siding with Zengi in case they attacked them, and their usefulness to destabilise the Muslim realms surrounding them; that doesn't mean that they saw them as allies, they considered their fanaticism nothing short of threat and were only waiting to eventually end with the order. The king and the prince started a campaign against the Assassin, to end their presence in the Levant once and for all. Quickly capturing Eiserre and later al-Kahf, without sparing a single soul that lived in this lands. An attempt was made in the life of the prince, but it was unsuccessful. Qadmus resisted for long, but it also fell. Masyaf was the greatest fortress they had in the region, it didn't fall easily, but after several unsuccessful assaults it was finally taken by October and every member of the order they could find was executed.

Sébastien-Melchior_Cornu_-_Prise_d'Ascalon_par_Baudoin_III_en_1153.jpg

Baldwin III of Jerusalem receiving capitulation of Ascalon, by Sébastien-Melchior Cornu

Ascalon and Jerusalem
Michael and Baldwin returned to Jerusalem, the general had made a deal with the king, Baldwin would accept Roman sovereignty over the principality of Antioch, while the army under Palaiologos would help him gain authority over his kingdom. Fulcher, the patriarch of Jerusalem, was persuaded to crown Baldwin for a second time, as Baldwin threatened him with giving more liberties to the greek church. Queen Melisende was convinced to back down after a letter from the emperor himself, giving the son control over the kingdom, though she would act as regent while he was on campaign.

Conrad wouldn't set foot on Jerusalem before ending his campaign, as he wanted to atone the sins he committed in the holy city. He wanted to end his campaign by taking Ascalon, as a way to symbolically complete what the heroes of the First Crusade had done, as the battle of Ascalon was the conclusion of their campaign. At the time the Fatimids of Egypt were weak, but the city was vast and its walls huge, it was nothing short of the greatest fortress the Fatimids had. The vizier had expected the event and prepared the city for the siege. Siege towers were constructed amd for months there were skirmishes between the defenders and the besiegers. The first setback of the defenders was of its navy, that was utterly defeated by the Genoese and Pisan navies. The second was when they tried burning a siege tower, the wind pushed the fire to the walls of Ascalon, a portion of them collapse and the city was nearly taken by assault. The last setback was once an army was organised to relieve the siege, king Baldwin intercepted near Gaza, and the Saracens were utterly defeated by a cavalry charge. The news panicked the population and the city surrendered, king Baldwin, pious man, let them leave in peace and the king took the city for himself.

Conrad finally marched to Jerusalem after the siege, his entry was an impressive spectacle, as the king made a procession around the walls of the city before his entry to atone for his sins. His first act was to march to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, were he met the assembled nobility. Louis soon arrived and emulated the procession. King Baldwin personally accompanied them on a tour of the Holy City, and later in the Holy Land in general, going as far as Mount Hermon. The kings stayed to celebrate a last Christmas in the Holy City ending their pilgrimage and thus the Second Crusade.

---

Author's notes:
So, this was a pretty long hiatus, I realised that I'm pretty bad at organising my time, now that I'm in classes, and didn't write anything the first week, so instead of publishing the chapters immediately after writing them I chose to have at least 10 chapters prepared in advance (at least I will try) and make the timeline of events at least up to the 1180's, to have at least some consistency when uploading. So, now I will be more constant, basically. I wish you have liked this chapter so far, I think it's quite good.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure if I should ask this here, but... Which program do you use to make maps? Like you know these fictional maps of TLs, like is it Photoshop or what? I really want to make a map for the next chapter and maps for this series in generak as it will be about the aftermath of the crusade, so I think is fitting as it will talk about the consolidation of the new frontiers. And is there a tutorial or something?
 
I'm not sure if I should ask this here, but... Which program do you use to make maps? Like you know these fictional maps of TLs, like is it Photoshop or what? I really want to make a map for the next chapter and maps for this series in generak as it will be about the aftermath of the crusade, so I think is fitting as it will talk about the consolidation of the new frontiers. And is there a tutorial or something?
I'd honestly use the website MapChart and actual historical maps to create your own maps. My computer has Paint 3D which I use for other edits.

Great chapter, keep up the great work 👍👍👍
 
I'd honestly use the website MapChart and actual historical maps to create your own maps. My computer has Paint 3D which I use for other edits.

Great chapter, keep up the great work 👍👍👍
Thank you very muchhhhh, the site seems pretty interactive, I really needed it
 
Top